Includes bibliographical references.

Thunderclap -- The House -- Sisters -- The Letters -- Fishing -- The Knock -- Waiting The News -- Temptation -- The Taxi Lady -- The Children -- The Women -- Amish Stud -- Dancing in the Rain -- Friends -- The Go-To Attorney for Wayward Amish -- the viewing -- Eli and Barb -- Warrants -- Barb in Jail -- Jailhouse Talk -- Eli in Jail -- Evidence -- A Husband's Questions -- Too Much Information -- Defense -- Prosecution -- Preparation -- Trial -- The Shot -- Best Friends -- It Was Lust -- It Was Lust II -- Doubt -- Verdict -- Aftermath.

Gregg Olsen and Rebecca Morris investigate the 2009 death of an Amish wife and mother found murdered in her own bed.